The decisions we agonise over that guests rarely notice
- Jenny McNeill
- Jan 20
- 2 min read

If an experience feels effortless, it’s usually because someone (cough) has spent an decent amount of time worrying over things no one will ever comment on.
At Feast & Fable, a lot of our work lives in that space.
Not the big, wow moments - those are the easy part. The real effort goes into the micro-decisions that shape how an experience feels in the room, rather than how it looks on in the deck.
Here are a few of the things we spend time debating that rarely make it into a review.

PACING - How long a guest should wait between moments.
Not just between courses, but between stimulus. Too fast and it feels rushed. Too slow and attention drifts. There’s a rhythm to an evening that can’t be templated - it has to be felt, tested, adjusted.

FIRST IMPRESSIONS - Where the first bite lands emotionally.
The opening mouthful sets a tone. It tells you whether you’re in safe hands. Whether this is generous or restrained. Whether you should relax or stay alert. We’ll change an entire menu if that first note feels wrong.

SIGN-POSTING - How much information a guest actually needs.Explanations can reassure and help the concept land - but they can also pull you out of the moment. We constantly decide what to say, what to show, and what to let people discover for themselves. We shouldn’t need to over explain for guests to follow.

SERVICE - When service should be visible - and when it should disappear.
Good service isn’t always noticed. Sometimes the best thing it can do is get out of the way. Other times, it needs to step forward and steer the room. That balance is never accidental. With Nutcracker Noir, the service was always flattered, in every review.

TUBE TALKING POINT - What people remember on the way home.
The final taste, the last interaction, the quiet moment after the noise drops. These details rarely get photographed, but they’re the ones that stay.
None of this is glamorous. It doesn’t read well in a pitch deck, but exists deep in a pre-production meeting. And most guests will never know it was considered at all.
But that’s kind of the point.
When these decisions are made well, people don’t talk about them. They talk about how the night felt. Calm, or perhaps immersive, thoughtful, easy, sensational, disruptive. Whatever the emotional objectives of the story were.

We don’t want them worrying about logistics.
And if we’ve done our job properly, the effort stays invisible - exactly where it belongs.




Comments